In case this is of interest....would love to hear any feedback on approach used <https://twitter.com...

# compose-ios

[John O'Reilly]

In case this is of interest....would love to hear any feedback on approach used https://twitter.com/joreilly/status/1655289995094106112?s=20

[Albert Chang]

First, you can use onSizeChanged instead of onGloballyPositioned. The former is called less often.
Second, if I understand it correctly, your UI requires a second frame to settle down, which is bad both UX-wise and performance-wise. IMO just migrating the whole screen to compose is much better.

[John O'Reilly]

Hmm, I had initially tried onSizeChanged but that didn't seem to work

[John O'Reilly]

Also don't have strong opinion on whether this is generally good approach....just exploring possibilities right now

[John O'Reilly]

But I do agree from what I've seen so far that sharing a whole screen does seem to make more sense.

[tylerwilson]

How about skipping SwiftUI in this case and do pure UIKit?
In my existing app, since I have not put in too much SwiftUI (and what was done was painful), I am leaning towards only using Compose for iOS as embedded UIViewController within other UIViewControllers, keeping all navigation pure UIKit and using RxSwift for any state management...

[tylerwilson]

I have been disappointed at how SwiftUI is tied to iOS releases, so if they fix a bug in one version you need, you rare forced to update. Whereas Compose works back to API 21, which is quite nice.

[John O'Reilly]

I've generally been trying this with existing projects that are already using SwiftUI

[Albert Chang]

This is definitely not a good approach and I would say it's better to make that clear in your post, and ideally also include the drawbacks.

[John O'Reilly]

the post was very much phrased as an exploration and not a recommendation

"This is work in progress and still some open questions but writing this article to capture what I’ve tried so far (will update if/when there are better approaches for doing anything shown here)."

[John O'Reilly]

I've seen examples elsewhere, including talk at KotlinConf, of sharing Compose based UI components like this within existing SwiftUI screen......when you say "this is definitely not a good approach" do you mean in general when doing this or specifically when including in ScrollView as per my post where that measurement stuff is needed?

[tylerwilson]

I would definitely never say definitely, but as mentioned I would expect it to be a valid architecture and any issues worked out where they may be found. Perhaps there needs to be a UIView wrapper like there is a UIViewController wrapper that is perhaps smarter about taking part in a ScrollView / UITableView / UICollectionView...

[Albert Chang]

The latter. I've explained that in my second point. See also this thread.