Hi is someone knows what is difference between `Tw...

# detekt

[Atul Gupta]

Hi is someone knows what is difference between Twitter's Jetpack Compose Detekt Rules and KODE Compose Detekt Rules ? Like in terms of philosophy or customisation?

[Atul Gupta]

I am planning to add compose on one of my android project wanted to know which should be picked?

[LeoColman]

To be completely honest, until your message I didn't know about any of those, and I use compose for everything 😅

[Atul Gupta]

Those two Detekt marketplace plugins for compose specific rules
1. https://github.com/appKODE/detekt-rules-compose
2. https://github.com/twitter/compose-rules https://github.com/mrmans0n/compose-rules

[LeoColman]

Cool!

[LeoColman]

Personally, with a very quick look, I find AppKODE to be closer to what I do in my Compose projects, and would probably be my choice.

Twitter didn't release compose-rules yet (version 0.0.x) while Kode has (version 1.3.x)

[LeoColman]

Twitter rules seem to be more extensive, and restrict more what you can do, for example https://twitter.github.io/compose-rules/rules/#make-dependencies-explicit

[LeoColman]

So by the looks of it I felt it will nag me much more than KODE

[Atul Gupta]

thanks for the analysis… Although Twitter one has more stars.

Also side-note twitter link shared above is not maintained Current maintained one is https://kotlinlang.slack.com/archives/CJLTWPH7S/p1700228648542809?thread_ts=1700228424.747159&cid=CJLTWPH7S

[LeoColman]

I also look at stars to judge libs, but I think it's a bit unfair to consider Twitter stars. It's an enormous player so stars flow in

[LeoColman]

The fork is also not released, v0.3.3. This can also mean nothing, Kover for example is still unreleased

[LeoColman]

Twitter one is deprecated after the layoffs

kodee angry Fuck that Musk guy kodee sad

[zt]

Personally I feel like this here is the best available https://github.com/mrmans0n/compose-rules

[Brais Gabin]

I use the KODE one too. Very happy with it.

[Marek Kubiczek]

Side question: can any of these be applied to Android Studio detekt plugin so I can see warning as I code and not only when I run Gradle detekt task? I failed with the Twitter rules, I guess they might be few versions behind current detekt and as such may be not compatible with latest detekt plugin 🤔

[navczydev]

Twitter rules now maintained by slack folks

[navczydev]

@Marek Kubiczek I have integrated the compose twitter rules with plugin and works as expected

[Atul Gupta]

@navczydev what about https://github.com/mrmans0n/compose-rules?

[navczydev]

Yes, I am using this 1 as its actively maintained. Added the jars to the plugin's config and it works as expected