Is there a way to access the `remember`ed value fr...

# compose

[Uli Bubenheimer]

Is there a way to access the `remember`ed value from the prior composition when re-calculating a new value upon recomposition? I see that the internal implementation of remember has access to the prior value, but does not expose it. Is there an API that does?

This can be done via an effect, but this implies an additional recomposition to use the new value.

I need this for updating a list that blends old values with new values from changed inputs. Right now I'm working around the issue with a second `remember`ed MutableState that is updated to the prior value on every recomposition. Seems ridiculously complicated when remember already has the info, just won't make it available.

This is what I want, conceptually; I am aware that the API would have to look a little different to accommodate initial calculation:

val list = remember(modelData) { priorValue -> mergeUpdatedList(priorValue, modelData) }

[Zach Klippenstein (he/him) [MOD]]

Trying to do this is typically a code smell.
• Why are you merging lists in your view layer, instead of your presentation/ViewModel layer or above?
• Composition isn’t guaranteed to see intermediate values if states are changed very quickly, which means for this sort of thing your code might not see all the values you expect.

[Uli Bubenheimer]

@Zach Klippenstein (he/him) [MOD] This is for integrating a legacy component (GoogleMap Marker) into Compose. The Marker owns the data (Marker position) after initialization. (Technically I am integrating with android-maps-compose MarkerState, it carries forward the Marker's ownership model.)
So there are 2 competing sources of truth here that I am merging in the list: initial source of truth is the app's data model, afterwards the source of truth is the Marker. There are a bunch of Markers, which I need to organize in a list-like structure that is needed as an input by another legacy component.
This question is not about states, it is related to slots. A slot has a well-defined prior value from the preceding composition, after the initial composition.

[Uli Bubenheimer]

What I need boils down to this modified Composer.cache() implementation. It uses @ComposeCompilerApi calls, and the original Composer.cache() is @ComposeCompilerApi as well. What are the implications of redefining and leveraging @ComposeCompilerApi functions in app code?

inline fun <T> Composer.cache(
    invalid: Boolean,
    initial: @DisallowComposableCalls () -> T,
    block: @DisallowComposableCalls (T) -> T
): T {
    @Suppress("UNCHECKED_CAST")
    return rememberedValue().let {
        if (it === Composer.Empty) {
            val value = initial()
            updateRememberedValue(value)
            value
        } else if (invalid) {
            val value = block(it as T)
            updateRememberedValue(value)
            value
        } else it as T
    }
}