Below dialog does not dismiss when clicked outside. Am I missing something or is this expected? Only...

# compose

[Rok Oblak]

Below dialog does not dismiss when clicked outside. Am I missing something or is this expected?
Only usePlatformDefaultWidth=true dismisses it when clicked outside.

Dialog(onDismissRequest = {...
    }, properties = DialogProperties(
        usePlatformDefaultWidth = false,
    ), content = {
        Surface(modifier = Modifier.fillMaxSize().padding(56.dp)
        ) {

[Skaldebane]

Not super familiar with Compose dialogs, but I think that's because usePlatformDefaultWidth causes the content to span the whole screen?

[Winson Chiu]

If you're filling max size, there is no outside to click on.

[Rok Oblak]

Thanks both, I guess it's that, I thought giving the surface padding would suffice but I'll have to manually check for clicks "inside"

[Skaldebane]

Yeah, and in particular material's Surface actually blocks touch passthrough

[Skaldebane]

Unsure about this, but it should work if you use a regular Box to apply the padding, the the surface inside it.

[Winson Chiu]

I think you'd still have to handle the click manually on the Box, but maybe not and the dialog catches unhandled clicks.

[Winson Chiu]

Alternatively if your goal is an inset dialog, technically you could do .width(windowWidth - padding) and the click outside should just work.

[Rok Oblak]

Yep that worked, thanks!