hello, i use a `Slider` and noticed that the `onV...

# compose

[trashcoder]

hello,

i use a Slider and noticed that the onValueChangeFinished is executed before the onValueChange event when i do not drag the slider but simply click on a new location:

I/System.out: onValueChangeFinished: 76.77
I/System.out: onValueChange: 15.1843815

when i drag, everything works as expected:

...
I/System.out: onValueChange: 72.501526
I/System.out: onValueChange: 72.402824
I/System.out: onValueChange: 72.451195
I/System.out: onValueChange: 72.36809
I/System.out: onValueChange: 72.342735
I/System.out: onValueChange: 72.66811
I/System.out: onValueChangeFinished: 72.66811

is this a known issue?

EDIT: moved source snippets to thread.

[trashcoder]

source snippets:

var brightness by remember(dimming.brightness) { mutableStateOf(dimming.brightness) }

...

Slider(
    value = brightness,
    onValueChange = {
        println("onValueChange: $it")
        brightness = it
    },
    modifier = Modifier.weight(1f),
    valueRange = dimming.range,
    onValueChangeFinished = {
        println("onValueChangeFinished: $brightness")
        onLightStateChange.invoke(light.id, light.isOn, brightness)
    }
)

[Rick Regan]

There is this issue “Inconsistent order of onValueChange and onValueChangeFinished callbacks from Slider” which is indirectly marked closed (through the one marked its duplicate). Maybe you’re on an old version or this hasn’t really been fixed.

[trashcoder]

thanks for your answer! i will check my version and try to update.

[trashcoder]

i updated gradle plugin "org.jetbrains.compose" from 1.1.1 to 1.2.0 and now the error is gone. thanks again! :)