Jigsaw is lining up to be a mess, as previously su...
# randomf
fellshard
04/10/2017, 12:42 AMJigsaw is lining up to be a mess, as previously suspected.
n
noctarius
04/10/2017, 5:08 AMSince the EC has to vote about it, gimme all the reasons necessary for a no 😉
fellshard
04/10/2017, 6:18 AMI wonder how many other JVM languages will be heavily impacted by these changes.
n
noctarius
04/10/2017, 6:20 AMGreat thanks, yeah I agree, the problem is, to vote no you have to have reasons, for a platform release those reasons most probably need to be extremely meaningful
noctarius
04/10/2017, 6:20 AMI think there was never ever a no vote on a platform spec so far 🙂
noctarius
04/10/2017, 7:37 AMgreat collection, not too much new stuff but great to see the issues in actual real-world
s
sksk
04/10/2017, 1:42 PMfrom what i understand it is the same thing as .NET Core, why it should be a mess for java and something good for .NET ? why this hate ?
n
noctarius
04/10/2017, 1:48 PMwell.. How many applications work with .NET Core? .NET Core is a completely new rewrite not something forced into the existing .NET lib
noctarius
04/10/2017, 1:48 PMI think there’s a huge difference here
f
fellshard
04/10/2017, 2:06 PMI need to do a deeper comparison between what .NET Core's package system, Jigsaw, and Maven:
A. Intended to solve,
B. Users wanted to solve, and
C. Actually accomplished.