Hi Is this going leak the memory Shared view model concept

Question

Hi Is this going leak the memory Shared view model concept <https developer android com topic libraries architecture viewmodel sharing> Both fragments takes the reference of Activity View model activityView model stay as long as activity stays does it going to keep the sharedviewmodel reference once it is created till the point activity destroys

Joost Klitsie · Answer

It will keep the same reference as how long the Activity is running

Joost Klitsie · Answer

so it will stay the same instance as long as the activity is not fully destroyed

Joost Klitsie · Answer

You can scope ViewModels to live die with Activities Fragments and otherwise with Navigation graphs or make some custom ViewModelStoreOwner implementation yourself but I don t think it is necessary

Joost Klitsie · Answer

so if you for example have a 1 activity architecture using the JetPack Navigation you can create nested graphs that share a ViewModel within the graph and once you get out of the graph the ViewModel gets cleared destroyed

Joost Klitsie · Answer

So for example If you have a navigation graph and you have inside a nested registration graph then all the fragments within the registration graph could share some RegistrationViewModel and once your registration is over you go to some other graph and the RegistrationviewModel is cleaned up slightly smiling face

Chethan · Answer

I did memory profiling on this I have single activity numerous fragment in the app This shared view model instance creates when I got into fragment and then on it stays like in the screen shot

Joost Klitsie · Answer

yes that is how it is expected to work and it is not leaking memory

Joost Klitsie · Answer

If your ViewModel is activity scoped it will be created once upon first usage and then that reference will be kept until the activity scope ceases to exist aka activity destroy

Joost Klitsie · Answer

so if that scope is too much for you you have to find a smaller scope which can be a navigation graph scope or Fragment scope

Chethan · Answer

that s what I am thinking swallow size is nothing but size of object its self nothing but instance of sharedview model in the fragment Inside sharedviewmodel I have one single property ```val isUserPostedSuccessfully = MutableLiveData lt Boolean gt false ``` if there is leak then it would have showed some number in deallocation

Chethan · Answer

Yes you are true it creates once and then that reference will be kept until activity scope my scope is not heavy and not retaining anything heavy I am not damaging much is this right solution for fragment communication if this reference going to kept

Joost Klitsie · Answer

I often use activity scoped or sometimes navigation graph scoped viewModels but I do have multiple activites slightly smiling face I would say that if it is rather a small thing it wouldn t clog the memory