Why

ReceiveChannel.toSet()

and

ReceiveChannel.toMap()

are

ObsoleteCoroutinesApi

but

ReceiveChannel.toList()

is not?

toList is basic we’ll likely leave it. Others will be likely moved to new apis

Ok, thanks.

But

Iterable.asReceiveChannel()

was at the same status, and in 1.0.0 it disappeared @elizarov. Will all the other

ObsoleteCoroutinesApi

at least go through a deprecation stage before being removed, or might they be removed suddenly?

@dave08, Based on this discussion: https://github.com/Kotlin/kotlinx.coroutines/issues/632 There will be deprecation stage and migration aids

@Jonathan Thanks, I just got scared since, in the 1.0 api review asReceiveChannel was deprecated, and then in 1.0.0 it seems like it was suddenly removed. Even though I got the same answer... https://kotlinlang.slack.com/archives/C1CFAFJSK/p1540402626000100?thread_ts=1540400798.000100&cid=C1CFAFJSK. I guess that'll change with 1.0.0 🙂

1.0.0 is stable and it means nothing is going to be disappearing anymore.

I thought the experimental/obsolete parts are still not stable... thanks for confirmation that there'll be no more sudden disappearing 🙂! I started wondering if I should copy obsolete things I used frequently into my code...

If we break something accidentally, file a bug and we’ll fix it.