Is it possible to mix fragment and composable dest...

# compose

[Luke]

Is it possible to mix fragment and composable destination in a NavHost? I want to add a fragment that I don’t own, from a library, as a destination. I tried:

NavHost(
    navController = navController,
    startDestination = route,
) {
    composable(...) { ... )
    fragment<LibraryFragment>(id)
}

But when I run, the activity crashes with Could not find Navigator with name "fragment". You must call NavController.addNavigator() for each navigation type. If it’s not possible, is there another way to add a fragment to composition?

[Ian Lake]

This is not possible via Navigation Compose, no.

[Ian Lake]

I don't know what the latest is on adding a fragment within a Compose hierarchy is (to be somewhat honest, I'd be surprised if it works consistently), but I would imagine it would involve an AndroidView or AndroidViewBindin (if you want to inflate a FragmentContainerView with an android:name) ala: https://developer.android.com/jetpack/compose/interop#views-in-compose

[Luke]

I’ll try the view binding approach. Thanks for your hindsight

[Ian Lake]

If you look at apps like JetChat, it generally uses fragments as the outer layer in a hybrid app, but with each screen (i.e., each fragment) implementing its UI in Compose, rather than implementing everything in Compose then adding fragments, etc. within that hierarchy

[Ian Lake]

Definitely do file bugs against Compose if you run into issues with that approach though - ideally, both approaches work

[allan.conda]

I tried AndroidView with a Fragment before, there’s still a crash when you’re using hardware keyboard in an emulator though it got fixed recently
https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/165034731
Will be available in the next release