Is there a reason why `rememberDismissState` doesn't receive `vararg inputs: Any?` kind of anchor t...

# compose

[Halil Ozercan]

Is there a reason why rememberDismissState doesn't receive vararg inputs: Any? kind of anchor to reset the state if some of the dependencies change? This certainly proved a challenge when I wanted to use SwipeToDismiss on list items. Because Lazy APIs reuse the same composable with different data, dismissState has to reset everytime the data changes.

[Halil Ozercan]

Also on the subject of SwipeToDismiss , it only supports horizontal direction. I happened to achieve a very satisfactory result by just adding an orientation argument and selectively choosing offsetX or offsetY according to the orientation.

[Adam Powell]

Please file it so that we have record of it. I'd like to make many of these custom rememberFooState functions go away in favor of more standard uses of remember itself, but each case we need to address has needed some thinking

[Adam Powell]

Many things involving animation currently read the ambient animation frame clock, which we're moving over to be provided in CoroutineContexts launched from composition, so all of those get simpler. We'll probably take a similar approach for fling-related information which takes the density into account.

[Halil Ozercan]

Filed issues for both

[Sean McQuillan [G]]

If you run into future issues like that, you can also work around them using they key API before the library fixes get in.

https://developer.android.com/reference/kotlin/androidx/compose/runtime/package-summary.html#key