BottomNavivation

composable (green accent) has a different ripple than

BottomNavigationView

(red accent) from Material Components for Android (which is the same effect showed in the material guidelines)

By 'different' do you mean the color of the ripple? Or the shape of the ripple? In either case I believe the Compose implementation is correct and up to date with the latest Material specs, and the

BottomNavigationView

implementation is out of date / incorrect here

Both the shape and the color. Anyway I think this is something that should be easily customizable. On Android a lot of apps (google apps like YouTube, Photos, Maps, Drive) use an unbounded colored ripple for the bottom navigation

Oh sorry, I just realized I was looking at the wrong screenshots - the red one looks correct / how this should behave. Would you mind filing a bug here? The

selectedContentColor

parameter should also be used for the ripple color here. And the bounded ripple looks like a refactoring mistake, it should be changed back to being unbounded 🙂

@Louis Pullen-Freilich [G] https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/167972306

Thanks!