ReceiveChannel#consumeAsFlow() never completes? I wrote a short program to test this ``` fun main()...

# flow

[Abhishek Bansal]

ReceiveChannel#consumeAsFlow() never completes?

I wrote a short program to test this

fun main() = runBlocking<Unit> {
    val test = Test()

    launch(<http://Dispatchers.IO|Dispatchers.IO>) {
        println("Receive 1")
        test.getResponseChannel()
            .collect { println("Collect 1 $it") }
    }

    launch(<http://Dispatchers.IO|Dispatchers.IO>) {
        println("Receive 2")
        test.getResponseChannel()
            .collect {
                println("Collect 2 $it")
            }
    }

    launch(<http://Dispatchers.IO|Dispatchers.IO>) {
        println("Receive 3")
        test.getResponseChannel()
            .collect {
                println("Collect 3 $it")
            }
    }

    println("Sending A")
    test.responseChannel.send("A")
    println("Sending B")
    test.responseChannel.send("B")
    println("Sending C")
    test.responseChannel.send("C")
}

class Test {
    val responseChannel = BroadcastChannel<String>(BUFFERED)

    fun getResponseChannel(): Flow<String> {
        val channel = responseChannel.openSubscription()
        return channel
            .consumeAsFlow()
            .onCompletion {
                println("Cancelled")
                channel.cancel()
            }
    }
}

Here you will see that onCompletion() and hence “Cancelled” never prints. My requirement is to be able to add and detach observers to a broadcast channel. It that achievable?

[Dennis]

You never close the broadcast channel? https://kotlin.github.io/kotlinx.coroutines/kotlinx-coroutines-core/kotlinx.coroutines.channels/-send-channel/close.html

[Dennis]

The child channels/flows only complete when upstream closes or the channel closes. Who will close the channel/flow?

[Abhishek Bansal]

Broadcast channel is meant to live throughout the process lifecycle in my use case. I just want to subscribe and unsubscribe on the fly

[Abhishek Bansal]

is that even possible?

[Dennis]

Yes, but then you have to close the flow or the underlying (child)channel

[Dennis]

You only get the onCompleted if the underlying channel gets closed. The flow stays ‚active‘ until this happens

[Abhishek Bansal]

Right, the only way that I see now is to send ReceiveChannel to my upper layers all the way to ViewModels and call consumeAsFlow there. Save this channel and call cancel on collect.

[Abhishek Bansal]

otherwise I am not sure how and when to close the flow without OnCompletion

[Dennis]

What’s the lifetime scope of this consumer/flow? If you have a coroutinescope that gets cancelled then it will close the flow as well (if you collect from this scope), right?

[Abhishek Bansal]

its defined by viewModelScope if you are familiar with Android AAC.

[Dennis]

I‘m not, but if this is a coroutine scope then just make sure to call flow‘s collect from this scope. Then structured concurrency takes care of it.

[Abhishek Bansal]

This scope doesn’t get destroyed actually.. but I see what you mean. I can probably create a child scope and collect flow there.

[Dennis]

Yes. You need something that knows the lifetime of this flow

[Abhishek Bansal]

yeah cool. I will try that and let you know. To be honest my basics around coroutines and flow are not as strong as of now. Sorry for trouble!

[Abhishek Bansal]

okay so creating a child coroutine and cancelling is explicitly in collect does the trick for me. Its a bit non obvious and convoluted right now but works till I get something better. Thanks for going deep in my problem and all your help.