Is there a way to build a universal pkg (Intel + A...

# compose-desktop

[Thomas]

Is there a way to build a universal pkg (Intel + ARM64) for Mac? That is needed to be able to upload it to the Apple AppStore.

[Alexander Kurasov[JB]]

You can try to add both MacOS dependencies instead of

implementation(compose.desktop.currentOs)

use

implementation(compose.desktop.macos_arm64)
implementation(compose.desktop.macos_x64)

In my undestanding it should include both platform binaries into the bundle

[Thomas]

Thanks, I gave it a try but when doing a right click and get info on the produced .app it still shows Apple Silicon instead of Universal.

I am building the project on an M1 Mac with an ARM64 JDK.

I am not sure what to do about the bundled JRE. Would I need to include it twice (for Intel and for ARM64) or so?

[Alexander Kurasov[JB]]

That is a good question. Could I ask you to create an issue on github, since the topic seems to be an important one

[Thomas]

Sure. Should I create a single issue for all Apple AppStore related issues and feature requests?

[Thomas]

I noticed some stuff that is missing in the jpackage task etc

[Alexander Kurasov[JB]]

Let’s start with a single issue. We can always split it later

[Thomas]

https://github.com/JetBrains/compose-jb/issues/1599

[Thomas]

@Alexander Kurasov[JB] I have been working on some fixes for the jpackage command, which is required for the App Store. Could you maybe take a look? https://github.com/JetBrains/compose-jb/pull/1613

[james]

@Thomas how far did you get with this?

it would be great to not have to switch between an M1 and an Intel mac just to build two different builds of our CfD applications

I also noticed this issue which appears stale, and I am wondering if there is some way we can contribute?: https://github.com/JetBrains/compose-jb/issues/518

cc: @Igor Demin

[Thomas]

Have not looked further into this yet. For now I am just uploading an Intel-only build. I think the solution would be: 1. build a universal intel/arm64 jar; 2. merge intel/arm64 JREs into one JRE at build time.

[Thomas]

For now I am quite busy with Windows but I plan to pick up the macOS issues in the coming months.

[Thomas]

There is an open issue about universal Mac build here: https://github.com/JetBrains/compose-jb/issues/1599

[Thomas]

Unfortunately it is not as easy as just building a universal jar, as the jre is not universal.

[Thomas]

@james if you have any ideas please share them

[Thomas]

To build a universal JRE, I think the way to go would be to use jlink twice. One time with an Arm64 JDK, second time with an Intel JDK. Then you have two JREs. Must be the exact same JDK version. Then merge the JREs manually using the Apple tools for this into a universal JDK. Then pass that universal JDK to jpackage. At least that is what I am going to try when I look into it again.

[Thomas]

I have not had the time to look into this further yet, it is not a priority for me at the moment.