is anyone using kodein successfully in a multiplat...
# multiplatformk
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 5:09 PMis anyone using kodein successfully in a multiplatform library w/ K/N?
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 5:10 PMi don't see how it could be used given K/N limitations w/ concurrency
k
kpgalligan
11/04/2019, 5:21 PMIt’s single threaded. There will be a koin multithreaded version soon-ish. I have a forked version, although no docs or whatever for now.
k
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 6:41 PMyeah I can't think of a scenario where single threaded injection is useful 😛
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 6:42 PMseems like that should be called out on their website
k
kpgalligan
11/04/2019, 6:42 PMWell, honestly, I guess it depends how you architect the app
☝️ 1
k
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 6:54 PMguess i'll rip that out and go with manual DI for the time being
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 6:54 PMi've only got a couple things being injected
o
olonho
11/04/2019, 8:59 PMHow DI and concurrency model ever relate to each other?
k
kpgalligan
11/04/2019, 9:05 PMIf the config isn’t static, then it realistically can only be accessed ever on the main thread. You can freeze the config, but would need to be aware that anything in there is also frozen, and then there’s singletons which are (generally) lazy, so the storage needs to be atomic or main thread only. That’s off the top of my head. The DI config and internals aren’t static, so they would need to be main thread only, or internally aware of the KN concurrency model (ie freezable with atomics). If main thread only, I’d assume you’d want something like ensureNeverFrozen and docs about that
kpgalligan
11/04/2019, 9:07 PMI’m not super familiar with kodein, except to say the version I last saw would compile on native but would fail once frozen. I’ve worked on a koin version that would function in native and multiplatform, but still needs finishing (discussing over the next few days, likely, at oredev)
o
olonho
11/04/2019, 9:09 PMwhy can’t there be an owner worker for config and all other worker ask for frozen config snapshots?
k
kpgalligan
11/04/2019, 9:09 PMThat would definitely mean the DI framework is aware of Kotlin Native’s model, yes 🙂
kpgalligan
11/04/2019, 9:12 PMYou can maybe use something other than atomics, but the way DI works means it needs to be designed in such a way that it’ll work in the native model. I could be totally wrong, but the last kodein version I saw was not designed to be frozen internally (nor the first version of koin multiplatform that was submitted). Also not designed with config isolated in a thread, to be clear
k
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 9:15 PMit definitely does not support being frozen
k
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 9:16 PMi replaced it with a dirt simple injector that satisfies my use case. it was an interesting exercise getting it to support
by inject()k
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 10:12 PMi'll save you the trouble - the talk is about creating your own object graph using a system of interfaces
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 10:12 PMclassic service locator
Kris Wong
11/04/2019, 10:14 PMin my case I created a simple map of super types to their implementations and use that for property injection using the
byKris Wong
11/04/2019, 10:15 PMi'll be interested once Koin releases multithreaded K/N support
k
Konstantin Petrukhnov
11/05/2019, 5:19 AM@Kris Wong do you have any code sample?
k
Kris Wong
11/05/2019, 2:27 PM