Hi after upgrading from http4k 3 251 to 3 252 or bey

Question

Hi < dave> after upgrading from http4k 3 251 to 3 252 or beyond i get 403 errors when my app receives the callback from an oauth provider This happens using the Apache server If I switch to Jetty or Netty the 403 problem goes away Is there something special I should configure when using the Apache server

dave · Answer

Hmm That s release was when we switched to the new version 5 of Apache server so it looks like there might tweaking to be done to the server implementation using the A5 APIs For the moment you can just use http4k server apache4 which should solve your problem Can you raise an issue with it we might need a contract of some type adding to make sure it works across the board

pabl0rg · Answer

Thanks

pabl0rg · Answer

I also hit some weird issues with the apache 5 client so i ll switch to apache 4 Here s a stack trace where i get an error

pabl0rg · Answer

```java net SocketException Socket is closed Socket java 1155java net Socket setSoTimeout BaseSSLSocketImpl java 633sun security ssl BaseSSLSocketImpl setSoTimeout SSLSocketImpl java 2577sun security ssl SSLSocketImpl setSoTimeout BHttpConnectionBase java 269org apache hc core5 http impl io BHttpConnectionBase fillInputBuffer BHttpConnectionBase java 277org apache hc core5 http impl io BHttpConnectionBase awaitInput BHttpConnectionBase java 285org apache hc core5 http impl io BHttpConnectionBase isDataAvailable DefaultBHttpClientConnection java 65org apache hc core5 http impl io DefaultBHttpClientConnection isDataAvailable DefaultBHttpClientConnection java 171org apache hc core5 http impl io DefaultBHttpClientConnection$1 checkForEarlyResponse DefaultBHttpClientConnection java 187org apache hc core5 http impl io DefaultBHttpClientConnection$1 write SessionOutputBufferImpl java 117org apache hc core5 http impl io SessionOutputBufferImpl flushBuffer SessionOutputBufferImpl java 126org apache hc core5 http impl io SessionOutputBufferImpl flush ContentLengthOutputStream java 99org apache hc core5 http impl io ContentLengthOutputStream flush ByteArrayEntity java 131org apache hc core5 http io entity ByteArrayEntity writeTo DefaultBHttpClientConnection java 209org apache hc core5 http impl io DefaultBHttpClientConnection sendRequestEntity HttpRequestExecutor java 148org apache hc core5 http impl io HttpRequestExecutor execute HttpRequestExecutor java 225org apache hc core5 http impl io HttpRequestExecutor execute PoolingHttpClientConnectionManager java 600org apache hc client5 http impl io PoolingHttpClientConnectionManager$InternalConnectionEndpoint execute InternalExecRuntime java 220org apache hc client5 http impl classic InternalExecRuntime execute MainClientExec java 107org apache hc client5 http impl classic MainClientExec execute ExecChainElement java 51org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement execute ExecChainElement java 57org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement$1 proceed ConnectExec java 181org apache hc client5 http impl classic ConnectExec execute ExecChainElement java 51org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement execute ExecChainElement java 57org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement$1 proceed ProtocolExec java 169org apache hc client5 http impl classic ProtocolExec execute ExecChainElement java 51org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement execute ExecChainElement java 57org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement$1 proceed HttpRequestRetryExec java 93org apache hc client5 http impl classic HttpRequestRetryExec execute ExecChainElement java 51org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement execute ExecChainElement java 57org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement$1 proceed ContentCompressionExec java 128org apache hc client5 http impl classic ContentCompressionExec execute ExecChainElement java 51org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement execute ExecChainElement java 57org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement$1 proceed RedirectExec java 116org apache hc client5 http impl classic RedirectExec execute ExecChainElement java 51org apache hc client5 http impl classic ExecChainElement execute InternalHttpClient java 178org apache hc client5 http impl classic InternalHttpClient doExecute CloseableHttpClient java 75org apache hc client5 http impl classic CloseableHttpClient execute CloseableHttpClient java 89org apache hc client5 http impl classic CloseableHttpClient execute ApacheClient kt 57org http4k client ApacheClient$invoke$1 invoke ApacheClient kt 47org http4k client ApacheClient$invoke$1 invoke ClientFilters kt 56org http4k filter ClientFilters$SetHostFrom$invoke$1$1 invoke ClientFilters kt 52org http4k filter ClientFilters$SetHostFrom$invoke$1$1 invoke Http4k kt 21org http4k core Http4kKt$then$2 invoke Http4k kt 1org http4k core Http4kKt$then$2 invoke AccessTokenFetcher kt 46org http4k security AccessTokenFetcher fetch OAuthCallback kt 27org http4k security OAuthCallback invoke OAuthCallback kt 11org http4k security OAuthCallback invoke internal kt 107org http4k routing TemplateRoutingHttpHandler$match$1 invoke internal kt 97org http4k routing TemplateRoutingHttpHandler$match$1 invoke routing kt 29org http4k routing RouterMatch$MatchingHandler invoke internal kt 77org http4k routing AggregateRoutingHttpHandler invoke internal kt 69org http4k routing AggregateRoutingHttpHandler invoke ServerFilters kt 233org http4k filter ServerFilters$CatchLensFailure$2$1 invoke ServerFilters kt 43org http4k filter ServerFilters$CatchLensFailure$2$1 invoke ResponseFilters kt 24org http4k filter ResponseFilters$Tap$invoke$1$1 invoke ResponseFilters kt 21org http4k filter ResponseFilters$Tap$invoke$1$1 invoke RequestFilters kt 23org http4k filter RequestFilters$Tap$invoke$1$1 invoke RequestFilters kt 19org http4k filter RequestFilters$Tap$invoke$1$1 invoke Log500 kt 13gt kemik http Log500$invoke$1 invoke Log500 kt 10gt kemik http Log500$invoke$1 invoke Http4k kt 21org http4k core Http4kKt$then$2 invoke Http4k kt 1org http4k core Http4kKt$then$2 invoke ServerFilters kt 252org http4k filter ServerFilters$CatchAll$invoke$1$1 invoke ServerFilters kt 248org http4k filter ServerFilters$CatchAll$invoke$1$1 invoke Http4k kt 21org http4k core Http4kKt$then$2 invoke Http4k kt 1org http4k core Http4kKt$then$2 invoke Apache4Server kt 36org http4k server Http4kApache4RequestHandler handle HttpService java 437org apache http protocol HttpService doService HttpService java 342org apache http protocol HttpService handleRequest Worker java 66org apache http impl bootstrap Worker run ThreadPoolExecutor java 1149java util concurrent ThreadPoolExecutor runWorker ThreadPoolExecutor java 624java util concurrent ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker run Thread java 748java lang Thread run```

pabl0rg · Answer

lt del gt This is how i configured the Apache 5 client lt del gt Nevermind I noticed just now that the client used for OAuth was not configured just the default

dave · Answer

Can you stick a debugging filter in the stack and post what causes the 403

dave · Answer

We can obvs look at it later just curious

dave · Answer

If you ve got time and the inclination you could check out the http4k by example repo and switch to Apache 5 server then try running RunnableEenvironment to see if it s something related to your specific env