Hi guys, Sometimes (pretty infrequently) we’re get...

# getting-started

[Jérémy CROS]

Hi guys,
Sometimes (pretty infrequently) we’re getting a crash on a piece of code that adds data to a list.
It’s pretty simple really, a private val mutableListOf() and the code that crashes just .add to that list.
Exception is: ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException
We’re not sure what the issue could be, only idea that comes to mind is 2 threads calling add at the same time.
• Anything else worth investigating?
• If it’s the most likely issue, is there a solution beside “dont call twice on different threads”
• Something like a thread safe list maybe?
Thanks! 🙏

[Sam]

I think multithreading is very likely to be the cause, based on the symptoms you described 👍

[Sam]

You have a couple of options to make it thread safe; the simplest is to use Collections.synchronizedList from Java

[Jérémy CROS]

Seems easy enough 🙂 Any drawback I should be aware of?
Out of curiosity, what would the alternatives be?
In case it matters, the use case is logging locations in a KML file, the location can come from multiple coroutines/flows in the codebase
Also, realizing this is not quite a kotlin specific question any longer, sorry about that 😕

[Michael de Kaste]

Its definitely threaded access to the list like @Sam mentioned.

An alternative would be:

synchronized(listToAddTo) {
    listToAddTo.add(thingYouAreAdding)
}

[Sam]

Drawbacks of synchronized lists:
• Synchronization is slow
• It’s not coroutine-aware, so waiting coroutines will be blocked, not suspended
• It doesn’t prevent other threading issues, like concurrent modification while iterating
Alternatives could be:
• Channels, if you’re using coroutines
• Other thread-safe lists like CopyOnWriteArrayList and LinkedBlockingQueue

[Kristian Nedrevold]

Can't you just wrap the operation in a mutex?

[Kristian Nedrevold]

Then you would just suspend the coroutine, so it should be better than using synchronized

[Kevin Del Castillo]

I was thinking the same, a Mutex should do the work and make the code suspendable

[Jérémy CROS]

Ok, thanks guys 🙂
Just making sure I get this correctly:

private val myList = mutableListOf<Data>()

fun logData(data: Data) {
    myList.add(data)
}

Becomes:

private val myList = mutableListOf<Data>()
private val mutex = Mutex()

suspend fun logData(data: Data) {
    mutex.withLock {
         myList.add(data)
    }
}

Correct?